So what happens when BP succeeds?

Daniel Rothschild
May 27th, 2010
Politics

This morning Karl Rove has an op-ed (can we call it a column yet?) in the Wall Street Journal forwarding the increasingly silly and increasingly CW talking point that the BP oil spill is Obama’s Katrina:

As President Obama prepares to return to the Gulf Coast Friday, he is receiving increasing criticism for his handling of the oil spill. For good reason: Since the Deepwater Horizon rig blew up on April 20, a lethargic Team Obama has delayed or blown off key decisions requested by state and local governments and left British Petroleum in charge of developing a plan to cap the massive leak. Now the slow-moving oil spill threatens Mr. Obama’s reputation, along with 40% of America’s sensitive wetlands. Critics include some of his most ardent cheerleaders, who understand that 38 days without an administration solution is unacceptable. Obama officials have it backwards: They talk tough about BP’s responsibilities but do not meet their own responsibilities under federal law. They should not have let more than a month go by without telling BP what to do. And they should avoid recriminations against their partner in solving the problem until after the leak is sealed.

Rove’s analysis is good political point scoring, to be sure, but it shouldn’t be mistaken for a serious argument. Let’s think for a moment about the counterfactual: Obama spent the last month in BP’s war room, personally directing the operation, failing to use his Magical President Powers to fix the leak. Then Karl Rove would have written this:

As President Obama enters his fifth week embedded with BP’s senior management, he is receiving increasing criticism for his handling of the oil spill. For good reason: Since the Deepwater Horizon rig blew up on April 20, a hyperactive Obama team has interfered with and second-guesses every British Petroleum decision, making it impossible for the company to develop a plan to cap the massive leak.

Now the slow-moving oil spill threatens Mr. Obama’s reputation, along with 40% of America’s sensitive wetlands. Critics include some of his most ardent cheerleaders, who understand that 38 days without a engineer-led solution is unacceptable.

Obama officials have it backwards: They talk tough about the federal government’s responsibilities but do not allow BP to do what it knows, which is manage oil production. They should not have tried to take control of the situation from day one. And they should avoid recriminations against their partner in solving the problem until BP has really been given a chance to try.

Moreover, most of Rove’s criticisms have little to do with the president, but rather a big, complicated, inflexible, and opaque federal bureaucracy — the same bureaucracy that mucked up the response to Katrina, leaving political egg on Bush’s face.

Over at NRO’s Corner, Jonah Goldberg is a voice of reason:

Don’t get me wrong, I’m usually singing from the same “It’s Obama’s Fault and We Know It” songbook. But I just can’t bring myself to agree with the folks who think that the BP spill is a major indictment of Obama. He may have handled the politics of this thing badly, by which I mean the P.R., but unless someone can explain how Obama could have “taken over” and fixed this faster, I think a lot of the criticism is overboard. Not all of it; it sounds like Bobby Jindal has some legitimate complaints. But the notion that B.P. isn’t motivated to cap this thing as quickly as possible and so therefore Obama needs to lean on BP harder is nothing short of crazy talk. Obama could have been on vacation for the last month and I’d bet the tempo of the BP operation wouldn’t have been one minute slower.

What I wonder is whether there is a wrinkle in Goldberg’s argument that’s not the fault of the administration but of Congress. For weeks, BP has been trying to stop the leak with dome caps, junk shots (do they know that that phrase means?), and top kills. Nothing’s worked so far, but eventually something will. Maybe this week, maybe next; the flow will be staunched or at least contained.

At that point, every Congressional committee with jurisdiction over energy, public lands, commerce, and the environment will dragoon BP officials before them and ask sanctimoniously, “Why didn’t you do [insert whatever procedure ends up working] first?” Whichever engineer and manager organized the working solution will be hailed as heroes, while the developers of junk shorts and top hats will be publicly mocked.

To what extent does this change BP’s incentives to cap this spill? Who knows? Despite an ostensible $75 million cap on liabilities facing BP, it seems to be a bipartisan consensus that they’ll end up paying more, since we’re not really so much into the rule of law right now.

Whatever the result, though, it’s untoward to have Congress utilizing 20/20 hindsight to second-guess technical decisions after the fact. But at this point, I suppose we should be used to it.

http://www.angryblog.org/ Brian Patrick Moore

Yeah, I had the same response. If BP really is a greedy evil oil company, then we should expect them to act as quickly as possible to… stop losing all that expensive oil. I have no problem with them being liable for damages as well.

I have no idea what anyone thinks Obama could do. Does the government keep oil-rig-spill-fixing experts on retainer? If so, then they would almost certainly be the same people BP is using, or some other rig-maintaining company. I'm no fan of Obama, but it's completely unfair to blame him for inaction. This “always do something” philosophy is starting to grate on me.
http://www.replicahandbagsite.com chanel handbags

Good read … headline catchy … good points, some of which I have learned along the way as well (humility, grace, layoff the controversial stuff). Will share with my colleagues at work as we begin blogging from a corporate perspective. Thanks!
http://www.bestbeijingescort.com shanghai escort

Hi there may I use some of the information here in this post if I provide a link back to your site?
http://www.escortshanghaiescort.com shanghai escort

I use Digg to find stories all the time. It’s great when you don’t have anything else to write about. Nice list.
http://www.massagebeijingmassage.com beijing escort

I’ll gear this review to 2 types of people: current Zune owners who are considering an upgrade, and people trying to decide between a Zune and an iPod. (There are other players worth considering out there, like the Sony Walkman X, but I hope this gives you enough info to make an informed decision of the Zune vs players other than the iPod line as well.)
http://www.no1shanghaimassage.com shanghai escort

We were discussing in class a artwork during the Renaissance period . It was a classy painting about life in general during those times. There were characters in the painting doing their daily habits and the painting was like a window of the earlier period.
http://www.beijingescortbeijingescort.info beijing massage

If you wanna lose weight fast, do what I did
http://www.beijingescortgirl.info shanghai escort

Awesome post peter, it’s been a long-time since I’ve been on here. I see that nobody has lost their passion. Good to be back.
http://www.beijingmassagebeijingmassage.info shanghai escort

Pretty terrific post. I found your blog and wanted to say your information seems legit. Will keep reading. Thanks. I would appreciate it if you visited my blog at
http://www.beijingmassagegirl.info shanghai escort

By doing so your blog becomes more appealing and interesting for your audience but in terms of SEO and search engines they love a fresh updating blog site.
http://www.shanghaiescortgirl.info shanghai massage

Where can it be, i’d like you just read much more about this particular post, thanks.
http://www.shanghaiescortshanghaiescort.info beijing escort

A truly very good publish by you my pal. We have bookmarked this web page and can occur again following several days to verify for just about any new posts which you make.
http://www.shanghaimassageshanghaimassage.info shanghai escort

You have a great article here, really helpful. Very well written I will be bookmarking this website and subscribing to your feed so i can regularly read articles of this quality.
http://www.shanghaimassagevip.info beijing massage

Why this web site do not have other languages support?
http://www.shenzhenescort.info beijing escort

i need some of those dumbell thingies but i cant… mum thinks i’m going crazy with fitness… oh well
http://www.shenzhenmassageshenzhenmassage.info shanghai massage

This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw.Thanks for posting this informative article.
http://www.51shanghaimsasage.com beijing escort

Hi administrator I take pleasure fromI like what you all have to say. Very straight to the point.
http://www.replicahandbagsite.com replica handbags

Thanks very much for this great Post. Good topic to write about on my site. I might set a bookmark to your blog.
http://www.replicahandbagshermes.com coach replica handbags

Nice to see you blogging about this good topic.
http://www.watchs-replica.net replica hublot watches

Precious Content! I had been simply just worrying that there’s a bunch bad additional info to this subject but you basically switched my personal advice. Thank you a beautiful publish.
http://www.watchs-replica.net omega replica watches

I am brand-new to blogging and actually loved your website. I am going to bookmark your web site and keep checking you out. Thanks for sharing your site.
http://www.watchhandbag.com replica cartier watches

I love reading your blog. You seem like a natural in sharing your experiences. I am starting my blog as well, do you think only natural writers can have something to share?
http://www.pornblocker.biz Perry Kornbau

I feel like I’m constantly looking for interesting things to read about a variety of niches, but I manage to include your blog among my reads every day because you have compelling entries that I look forward to. Here’s hoping there’s a lot more top-notch material coming!
http://www.watchhandbag.com replica rolex submariner

A truly amazing Post. Many thanks for sharing you?e wealth of Information with us After Once again. It? no wonder your blog does so well. Your site is well thought out, graphically impressive and full of great Assistance. Kudos.
http://www.yywatches.com Zenith watches

I’m impressed!!! Really informative blog post here my friend. I just wanted to comment & say keep up the quality work. I’ve bookmarked your blog just now and I’ll be back to read more in the future my friend! Also nice colors on the layout, it’s really easy on the eyes.
http://www.topareplicas.com chanel bags

I enjoy your layout, the particular inescapable fact that your webpage is actually a tad bit distinctive helps make it so useful, I get fed up of viewing same-old-same-old just about all of the time. I have I simply just happened on this page by you Appreciate it.
http://www.bestbeijingescort.com shanghai escort

hey i simply just want to say that this stuff never gets old, love it, carry on the great info, its better reading this than working for a living, cheers
http://www.escortshanghaiescort.com shanghai massage

Random question: I am starting my own blog to share my photography experiences. Do you find it hard or easy to post consistently?
http://www.massagebeijingmassage.com shanghai massage

Welcome First time jumped here on your site, found on Google. It really helps to have someone to talk to other then my divorced parents. Thanks again Mr. Grey.
http://www.no1shanghaimassage.com shanghai escort

Im grateful for the blog post.Thanks Again. Keep writing.
http://www.vipshangheiescort.com shanghai massage

I just visited your website via Facebook..
http://azimmigrationlaw.org Dian Cinco

Hello may I use some of the insight here in this post if I provide a link back to your site?
http://hair-removal.biz Gregory Poche

Hi there could I use some of the material from this blog if I provide a link back to your site?